Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 91 of 160
FirstPreviousNextLast
pyrhos (1268 D)
24 Jul 13 UTC
colonial 1885
I've made a colonial 1885 please join we need 8 more players. It's gameID=15287
2 replies
Open
Decima Legio (1987 D)
15 Jul 13 UTC
24 players variant
Having a look at the Variants page, there’s a big dark hole from the 19 players Haven to the giant variants Chaos and WWIV, respectively 34 and 35 players.
13 replies
Open
Alcuin (1454 D)
20 Jul 13 UTC
Draw at all costs or points?
gameID=13383

First of all, congratulations to Ruffhaus (Turkey) in winning this game. It's also interesting to see a game in which all of the global powers (Britain France and Holland, plus the biggest regional power (Russia) were defeated.
24 replies
Open
mendax (1260 D)
19 Jul 13 UTC
Conflict in the Rinascimento rules
http://vdiplomacy.net/variants.php?variantID=29

The text at the top states 33 SCs to win, the text lower gives a requirement of 30. Which is the case?
2 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
19 Jul 13 UTC
Chaos Gunboat
Anyone interested please join. gameID=15187. Seems like it will be a lot of fun and challenging. Not like your typical game.
0 replies
Open
SandgooseXXI (1294 D)
17 Jul 13 UTC
Replacement Needed
gameID=14935

Italy CD, still has good enough position for you to take over.
1 reply
Open
butterhead (1272 D)
16 Jul 13 UTC
(+1)
I need to step away...
Over the last couple of months, I have slowly been drifting away from Diplomacy. What used to be the excitement of coming online to see what has happened, has began do fade out. I realized that I have stopped thinking about the game with my head. That is why I must (temporarily) leave the game behind.
10 replies
Open
King Atom (1186 D)
16 Jul 13 UTC
WebDip Has Surpassed This Site in Disappointment...
I see more CD's/NMR's on WebDip, I get much more frustrated with the range of talent between players on WebDip, and there's often even a language barrier when I play on WebDip.

Discuss.
7 replies
Open
PlanetXXX13 (1198 D)
16 Jul 13 UTC
Anyone happy to play against my 11 year old son?
Thinking about a EvT game, just so he can get use to the movement first. It will be on my account, probably a 2 day turnaround. If someone else has son or daughter who would also like to learn, then we could pitch them against each other. Let me know and I'll set something up.
2 replies
Open
Ninjanrd (1248 D)
14 Jul 13 UTC
(+1)
Aberration V's Story
Here is a link to a variant that my friend and I are working on coding.
(inside for details)
17 replies
Open
cypeg (2619 D)
11 Jul 13 UTC
(+1)
Forum FAQ ;) or FAP
Over the year we exchanged ideas and raised problems in some interesting topics i.e. the default setting of Viking and WW4, improving the site, etc. I think it will be good to gather these links and have them either in the Help or some kind of a permanent forum post called FAProblems.

that way all this knowledge will not be lost in the wilderness. Plus, these are problems and puzzles that will frequently arise as more and more people encounter them.
6 replies
Open
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
04 May 13 UTC
Anyone up for a Known World 901 15x15 battle?
I've been wanting to play each power in this variant since I converted it to php, but mostly I have only played several different powers. The idea is simple: 15 games, 15 players, in each game you take control of a different power. Each game will be semi-anon (sign up below), 1 1/2 day phases, WTA, gunboat (this will dramatically cut down on the time commitment to messaging). So who's up for it?
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
04 May 13 UTC
(I'm open to changing the phase to 2 days as well)
DoubleCapitals (736 D)
04 May 13 UTC
Meh. After May 17.
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
04 May 13 UTC
I'm happy to start May 17.
bagatur (1800 D)
04 May 13 UTC
I am.
DoubleCapitals (736 D)
04 May 13 UTC
Crap. What's the bet size?
steephie22 (933 D)
04 May 13 UTC
" gunboat (this will dramatically cut down on the time commitment to messaging)."

No shit :P
Kinda figured out myself that you have to put less time in messaging when you can't :)

Seriously though, I might be in, but will they be played simultaneously or not?
How much games at a time? How much time

steephie22 (933 D)
04 May 13 UTC
between the games? Accidently pressed post reply, stupid mobile :(
Guaroz (2030 D (B))
04 May 13 UTC
The idea of making a set of games of one variant playing each time a different power until you played them all is very nice. The idea of making these games gunboat is fantastic. So instictively I'd be up for it.

Unfortunately, thinking of it a bit deeper, there are some points that force me to skip this.

I'm going to tell you them, just in case you might want to modify something in this event or to make up a second one running along this.
1. KW901 is LONG. According to the variant list, this is the second longer variant in average (30 turns). On a rough computation, these 15 games would take about 56 months (averagely). This would be a very long time for any event, even more for an event in which you play 15 times the same variant for more 4 years long.
I could consider a Map of max 10 players, max 24 turns average, max 1day/phase, that would mean roughly "only" 20 months, averagely. Playing 2 games at once, we could bring the duration down to 1 year or even something less.
2. Semi-Anon. Not sure what you mean, aside that it will be neither FullyAnon nor NonAnon. SemiAnon is a very wide concept and I usually don't like it. But I could change my mind if you explain what you exactly mean and why it would be needed (and why NonAnon couldn't be good).
3. WTA is not my favourite variant, but it could be ok. The best, IMO, would be neither WTA nor PPSC, but it would be making it a Tournament scoring. We could re-adapt Dixiecon (http://www.dixiecon.com/id9.html), that highly rewards solos, for a number of players higher than 7.
Making it a tournament would be much fun, but it would imply a serious organization effort, specifically in how to manage pauses, drop outs, etc.. that are inevitable in tournaments.

Captainmeme (1400 D Mod (B))
04 May 13 UTC
Semi-Anon means that you know who's in the game, but not what country they control - the game is anon, but a list is given beforehand of who is in it.
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
04 May 13 UTC
OK here we go.

* my initial crazy idea is to play all of the games at the same time. But we could amend this to playing 2 sets at the same time (one set of 8-games, one set of 7). I know KW901 is a long variant, but I'm really keen to play each power at least once! but at the average of 60 days per set...

* I'm not really interested in running a tournament, just to play each power in this variant once. Drop-outs are a serious problem, and would most likely effect each game at the same time. I'm open to suggestions about how to deal with this issue (whether we make a no NMR policy and find a replacement player for all the games effected at once, or whether we adopt a no NMR policy but find individual players on a case-by-case basis.)

*Semi-Anon is precisely what Captainmeme said. We have a sign-up list, but when the games start we don't know who plays what country. We'll have to have a non-player PM each player with the countries they will play in each game)

*unfortunately we are bound by the restraints of the site - we can't really change the point system to suit our needs. But I'm open to PPSC if that is what the majority want.

*Point buy-in will only be small (2 D?), but the RR requirement will be 90+

Interested parties:
kaner406 (WTA or PPSC)
DoubleCapitals (after May 17)
bagatur

maybes:
steephie22
Guaroz
Guaroz (2030 D (B))
04 May 13 UTC
Ok, thanks for clarifications. I can't handle playing more than 2 games at once so, if you're searching for a "non-player PM each player with the countries they will play in each game", I can volunteer for it.
diatarn_iv (1458 D)
04 May 13 UTC
Hi, put me in the maybes: I can play a couple of games at the same time, perhaps 3; but no more than that.
btw, i'd prefer ppsc



RUFFHAUS 8 (2490 D)
04 May 13 UTC
I'm interested. If it matters I favor WTA and larger point investments as I think both attract high quality players in terms of talent and dependability. But I enjoy the 901 map, and love the idea. As for any NMR policy, anything that doesn't seriously delay the games is fine. Delays kill games. NMRs are annoying, but apathy sucks!
Leif_Syverson (1400 D Mod)
04 May 13 UTC
Count me in..

I like the 90+ RR, 2 pt bet, WTA, gunboat, 2 day phases, and prefer not much more than 2 games at a time.

Btw, when are more known world variants coming out? 901 wasn't supposed to be the only one was it?
Leif_Syverson (1400 D Mod)
04 May 13 UTC
as for NMR policy, I'm with RUFFHAUS, feel free to replace NMR's immediately, but as long as we can fill them quickly. If the game drags on for a long time waiting for replacements we are likely to lose more (or at least lose interest).
I'm playing in the webDip 17x17 World map tournament (almost complete now). All 17 games ran at the same time, and as you could imagine it got to be a bit much. I really enjoyed playing several different nations at once, just not quite that many!

Put me on the definitely-maybe list. I would suggest coming to a consensus on the number of games to be concurrently running, and then as games end another will start to keep that number of games going. So if there are to be always 5 games running, then we start with 5 and each game that ends means another one begins. This would keep the overall duration to what, maybe 6 months? Another consideration for those not wanting even that many is that of 5 games, especially gunboat in which your top-notch diplomacy skills can't save you, at least one is likely to result in early defeat. So the actual game commitment is more likely to be 3-4.

My votes are:
5 games at a time (4-8 OK)
36-hour phases (24-50 OK)
WTA
10 point + buy in (I prefer playing for more, but I know this gets restrictive for some players. The number of concurrent games certainly factors as well).

As for CDs, I think we make a brief effort to find a replacement and otherwise press on. CDs suck, but I agree with Leif and RUFFHAUS.
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
05 May 13 UTC
So I think so far the consensus is for NMRs to be dealt with quickly, and for it being WTA. The voice of experience in this sort of thing is coming from Dr.R so I'm thinking 5 games to start, with a new game beginning as soon as one finishes.

Interested parties (6):
kaner406 (WTA or PPSC)
DoubleCapitals (after May 17)
bagatur
RUFFHAUS 8 (WTA)
Leif_Syverson (WTA)
Dr. Recommended (WTA)

maybes (2):
steephie22
diatarn_iv (PPSC)

PM'er
Guaroz

**We'll have to wait until the end of the year for some more variants to start coming out for me. The Known World 1200 is something that is in the pipeline as well as the Known World Venus.
Decima Legio (1987 D)
06 May 13 UTC
Since this is not meant to be a tourney, I’m open to play ½ of the games if someone else is willing to share the other half with me. Personally I do not plan to play all the 15 positions.
This way I could play 2 – 3 games at the same time and not more.


Other preferences:

Pot type: I’m fine with either PPSC-WTA. Whatever is the decision, just make sure that players accept to play according to the pot rule.

Speed: 24 to 30 hours/phase.

Bet size: same as Dr.R said

NMR policy: my favorite is ∞/1, but if this is the minority, I’m ok with anything else.
Lord Skyblade (1912 D)
07 May 13 UTC
Decima Legio, I would also like to play in half of them, because I don't think I'll have time after the summer ends, so if you'd be willing to let me take the first bunch I would definitely be up for it.
Amwidkle (1351 D)
07 May 13 UTC
I love Known World 901. Easily one of the best variants on the site. Add in gunboat style, the opportunity to play every country, and with reliable players too? I can't pass this up. Count me in.

With more concurrent games, we would have to have longer phases to compensate. No sense in having especially long phases when it's gunboat.. that just leads to boredom and probably even more NMRs in the long run. In the end I don't think running a bunch of concurrent games would save much time. My preference is for 12 hr or 24 hr phases with 2-3 games going at once, NMR/off. WTA or PPSC doesn't matter to me.
Amwidkle (1351 D)
07 May 13 UTC
Plus I fear playing 5+ concurrent games of Known World would lead to burnout (even for a Known World lover like me). Plus, having so many slots devoted to this project would eat up our availability to play other variants, or else disqualify those like myself who normally play at or near the max allowed number of games.
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
07 May 13 UTC
Interested parties (9):
kaner406 (WTA/PPSC, 5-games)
DoubleCapitals (after May 17)
bagatur
RUFFHAUS 8 (WTA)
Leif_Syverson (WTA)
Dr. Recommended (WTA)
Decima Legio (1/2 load, WTA/PPSC, NMR => ∞/1)
Lord Skyblade (1/2 load)
Amwidkle (WTA/PPSC, NMR/off, 2-3 games)

maybes (2):
steephie22
diatarn_iv (PPSC)

PM'er
Guaroz
Leif_Syverson (1400 D Mod)
07 May 13 UTC
I'm going to cast my vote for no more than 5 concurrent games, but I really want to participate in all 15..
Decima Legio (1987 D)
07 May 13 UTC
Lord Skyblade,
thanks for your interest, but I am seeking for someone to share the games "in parallel" with me, not "in series" with me, since I don't want to play more than 2 – 3 KW901games at the same time.
Unfortunately my requirements do not seem to match with yours
diatarn_iv (1458 D)
07 May 13 UTC
Decima's suggestion is more or less what my "maybe" meant. If 1/2 load means that, put me in that category

Btw, kaner, I "voted" PPSC; but if the majority opts for WTA, that's fine for me.
Other preferences:
speed: 36-48 hours/phase is best, 24-72h/phase is acceptable
bet: 10-20 D
NMR: no preference
B-RICH94 (1859 D)
27 May 13 UTC
Did this ever start? If you're still looking for people, I would be interested.
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
27 May 13 UTC
I'm still up for it, but due to some work commitments I can't start until 2nd week of June.
Bump :)
kaner, is this still something you are interested in doing?
Alcuin (1454 D)
10 Jul 13 UTC
I'm up for this but I have to start radiotherapy in October.
Gumers (1801 D)
10 Jul 13 UTC
Count me in.
DEFIANT (1311 D)
10 Jul 13 UTC
sure, it's a neat map.
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
10 Jul 13 UTC
Maybe towards the end of the year - things are starting to get busy for me again - nothing stopping anyone else from setting this up though.
Anon (?? D)
11 Jul 13 UTC
gameID=15162
One to tide us over?
General Cool (978 D)
13 Jul 13 UTC
Wow, I actually only had 42 D points, that's a fairly high bet.
fadethru (1125 D)
13 Jul 13 UTC
count me in!
Evil Minion (967 D)
14 Jul 13 UTC
Count me in.


37 replies
JOHAN-FINLAND (1528 D)
11 Jul 13 UTC
A question about orders
Hello! I have a question about a scenario that happened to me in a game for about a month ago. I hope somebody has time go look at it! I will post the question and map below.
12 replies
Open
SandgooseXXI (1294 D)
09 Jul 13 UTC
Movies you gotta see!
So, summer nights are here, and I'm looking for some good movies to watch. Taking suggestions. :D

Thanks!
15 replies
Open
Oli (977 D Mod (P))
10 Mar 13 UTC
Brainstorming about the extend-vote
What's your thoughts about the current state of this feature?

The idea of the extend is meant to prevent NRMs and spoil the game. Using this as a diplomatic tool is not an option. That's why the mods usually extend games on request. The 3/4-majority is just introduced, so a few minor powers couldn't abuse the system to take a game on hostage indefinitely (and cause more work for the mods again).
53 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
10 Jul 13 UTC
IMPORTANT
I will be gone for the next three days so I would appreciate an extend for A Midnight Walk gameID=13814 (it is gunboat so I cannot post in the game itself)
0 replies
Open
The Ambassador (1948 D (B))
08 Jul 13 UTC
(+4)
WW2 Facebook account
For those Dippers who like history mixed up with a modern take: http://pinterest.com/pin/20899585740368140/
17 replies
Open
zultar (1241 D)
08 Jul 13 UTC
Best Diplomacy Website
Hey guys, I was wondering what your most preferred Diplomacy website?
I am playing in playdiplomacyonline website as well but honestly I prefer this one more since it is more tactical and does not punish you for making wrong clicks.. What do you guys think?
8 replies
Open
Oli (977 D Mod (P))
25 May 13 UTC
(+2)
New feature, very early development-stage....
Interactive map.
You can use you mouse to make give orders to your armies.
43 replies
Open
pyrhos (1268 D)
06 Jul 13 UTC
Germany 1648
We have a Germany 1648 starting in 16h somebody please join we need one more player
1 reply
Open
Anon (?? D)
06 Jul 13 UTC
WW4 gunboat starting in 24 hours - players needed
Please consider joining gameID=14993. We've got half the players, just need some more.
2 replies
Open
kaner406 (2103 D Mod (B))
28 Jun 13 UTC
variant test time
http://lab.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=100
3 replies
Open
NigelFarage (1238 D)
03 Jul 13 UTC
Classic-Total Domination
I've created a classic-build anywhere map, with an EOG of 34 SCs (i.e., all of the SCs in the game). To play, you have to agree to certain rules (in comments) beforehand. Password is in comments.

Game link: gameID=15041
6 replies
Open
Lukas Podolski (1234 D)
02 Jul 13 UTC
Replacement needed
gameID=14661 as Turkey
not a very good position, but is not completely dead
1 reply
Open
Oli (977 D Mod (P))
09 Jan 13 UTC
(+3)
Input of an alternate scoring system needed...
As the Dpoints are not an ideal way to represent a players game-strenght I'm thinking about implementing an alternate rating system (in addition to the traditional Dpoints)
Any math experts here?
734 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
26 Jun 13 UTC
EUROPE 1939-GAME (bet set to 49)
gameID=14955

A nice map taking place in a very interesting time. Come and join, I hope we all are good communicators!
4 replies
Open
SandgooseXXI (1294 D)
28 Jun 13 UTC
Country switch
Just a question on this. Say I take over a game where a player is literally a year from burning to nothing and gets the defeat, is that put on my record?!
8 replies
Open
Synapse (814 D)
27 Jun 13 UTC
Sitter needed
From tomorrow until 11th July
4 replies
Open
KICEMEN17 (1075 D)
27 Jun 13 UTC
Sitter Needed June 30th-July 6th
Hello all. I'm gone on a trip from June 30th- July 6th. If anyone could watch over my account I would be very grateful. I'm in 6 games, pretty solid position in each. I hate to ask for an extend in all these games, as I see it unfair to the players. The reason I'm in many games (I've known about this trip) is because I thought where I was going had internet. This is not correct!
16 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
27 Jun 13 UTC
Seeking sitter(s) for Known World 901 anon gunboats
Friday through Monday morning. Great positions! PM if interested.

http://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=14585
http://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=14313
1 reply
Open
Page 91 of 160
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top